Answer 2 Kadalamittai's Riddle Post: E = Mc2

click image 4 full view

1. Rule 9
2. Rule 8
3. Rule 9,14
   
4. Working 1
   
5. Working 3
   
6. Working 2: possible house # 1
   
7. Check the possibility for all the workings and find out the common things.
   
8. Mainly nationality and smoke have more combination
   
9. So the person who has birds as pets and smokes Pall Mall would live in house 3. {look closely into the combinations from workings 4,5,6,8,9}
   
10. Rule 6: working 8 in house # 3
    
11. Working 4: possible house # 4,5
    
12. Working 5: possible house # 2,5
    
13. working 6: possible house # 2,4,5
    
14. Working 9: possible house # 2,5
    
15. Working 7: possible house # 2,4
    
16. Note: from workings 5,9 the possible house # 2,5 are the same
    
17. From working 7, if we assume house # 4, then the drinks of house # 4 class with the pets and drinks of house # 5. This is not possible because our combination of nationality is mainly with drinks and smoke.
    
18. So working 7 has only possibility: house # 2
    
19. Now working 9 possibility: house # 5
    
20. Now working 5 possibility: house # 2
    
21. Now working 6 possibility: house # 4
    
22. Now working 4 possibility: house # 5
    
23. German owns the Fish